Sunday, April 3, 2016

Much comes to Light and it's...Anticlimactic

Lords and Ladies, Knights and Maidens, I have to say… I am a little disappointed. How can the King Arthur we have just heard about be the King we have come to know so well? Yes, he seems a little idiotic, and makes his share of mistakes, but we do not expect him to fall this way. Remember Uther Pendragon? Now that was a King that deserved retribution for his actions. Yet Uther was never punished. Kings are not punished for their actions. That is the rule in the world in which we live. Regardless of the fact that Arthur slept with his sister and fathered a child, and the fact that he killed almost an entire generation of children, Arthur’s original sin was ignorance. How can our King be punished for that, when Kings who committed far worse escape unscathed?
Even if one accepts, with great difficulty, the downfall of King Arthur, the mode of his end is so pitiful. With all the adventures we have seen for the Knights of the Round Table, the thing that harms him and Camelot should be something worthy of fables and bards. We expect a magical beast, a horde of knights, a magic spell. Instead of all that, the catalyst for the banishing of Sir Lancelot and the near burning at the stake of Queen Guinevere is a spiteful young man. Mordred. Despite the fact that Mordred shares King Arthur’s blood, he has had no special training, or done anything of note other than stab a man in the back, and cry like a child when he is accused of running away from a fight.
tantrum temper tantrum throwing a fit
Yet this is the creature that manipulates King Arthur to harming himself and Camelot by bringing to light Guinevere's affair and eventually robbing Arthur and Camelot of Lancelot. The problem seems to be Arthur’s inability to abandon his rules and his responsibility to uphold the rules fairly. Mordred does not operate on such a code of honor.
We remember from Gawain’s run in with me and the green girdle that self preservation is the one valid reason for abandoning the rules of honor. Yet, King Arthur does not do this. Perhaps it is not Mordred’s manipulations that shaped the ending of this story, but Arthur’s own inability to bend and use practicality. In a way, that may be even sadder than being brought down by your own son.
disney ursula pathetic
Another disappointing turn of events was that of Queen Guinevere and Sir Lancelot. They seem to have become very meek in their old age. The pair seems to accept all the misfortunes that befall them, and even with a WARNING, do nothing to protect themselves. Is it that the reign of King Arthur has made Camelot so peaceful that the people of court have lost the ability to engage in twisty court politics?  Or is it that the passions of these star-crossed lovers has cooled in their old age? Do Lancelot and Guinevere seem so accepting of their misfortunes because they have gained some wisdom or retained their thoughtlessness and lack of foresight?  They are both still alive however, so their story must not be finished. Maybe we shall get more answers.

3 comments:

  1. I agree, the Arthur's downfall does seem rather anticlimactic, but like we discussed in class it does make sense. In addition to the reasons mentioned in class, if he had been defeated by some great beast, who then would kill the beast? If this crazy guy who kills giants and can kill 400 men with one swing of his sword is defeated in single combat, who then could possibly kill whatever kills Arthur?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have to agree with you here, Arthur and Guinevere seemed to have both fallen into a rather dull slump of their rule. They are growing old and tired. They seem to care little about the fact that Arthur has a son coming to murder him and his wife is sleeping with his best knight. I don't know how the future of Camelot will play out, but I hope Arthur never looses his dignity as king.

    Although, ultimately I could care less.

    Ysbaddaden

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that Lancelot and Guinevere should have heeded the warning that was given to them. Had Lancelot stayed in his room, none of these events would ever have happened. While I know how hard it is to be away from one's love, a little caution would have saved the country from civil war. He knew what was at stake and decided to go to Guinevere anyway. I'm all for being with the one you love, but when you know your actions could cause the deaths of innocent civilians and brothers at arms you should put aside your wants and focus on the needs of your fellow people.

    ReplyDelete